Modern LED technology

White versus black LED: contrast and sunlight

The colour of the packages around the LEDs, white or black, seems a detail, but helps determine how deep the black is and how legible the screen stays in bright sunlight. Black almost always wins there.

Choose your level:

Around every LED sits a small block. That block can be white or black.

A white block reflects the sunlight, which makes the black on the screen look a little grey. A black block instead swallows that stray light. As a result the black looks truly black, the colours stand out more, and the image stays sharp, even in full sun.

Not the colour of the light, but the colour of the LED package and the circuit board is the subject here (a ‘white LED’ here refers to a white package, not to white light colour). A white package reflects ambient light; under strong lighting the black therefore turns grey and the contrast falls.

Why black contrasts better

A black package with a black circuit board greatly lowers the surface reflection (according to industry data, to about 6–12%). As a result the black parts look deeper and the image more legible, especially in bright light. Industry measurements give outdoor screens a contrast ratio on the order of 3000:1 for black versus about 1000:1 for white; indoors the differences are even greater. Black LEDs also generally consume slightly less.

Contrast and brightness

Legibility in sunlight is an interplay: high intrinsic brightness (5,000–7,500 nits outdoors) and low reflection. Black SMD or COB packages with matte masks combine both. That is why modern outdoor screens almost always choose black LEDs.

Outdoor legibility is a question of contrast, not only of brightness. The effective (external) luminance contrast is the ratio between the luminance of the screen content and the ambient luminance reflected by the screen. In direct sunlight (tens of thousands of lux) the reflected component dominates; lowering the surface reflection therefore directly raises the contrast.

Black-body packaging

A ‘black-body’ SMD uses black reflector cups and a black substrate instead of white, which reduces surface reflection to about 6–12%. Reported contrast ratios: outdoor ~3000:1 (black) versus ~1000:1 (white), indoor ~10,000:1 versus ~3000:1 (industry measurements). Besides contrast, this improves colour saturation under daylight; consumption is slightly lower. The trade-off was historically the more difficult production and higher cost of black packages.

A question about LED displays? Contact us

What are you looking for?